Past Reviews

Regional Reviews: St. Louis

Ragtime
Stages St. Louis
Review by Richard T. Green

Also see Richard's reviews of Dial "M" For Murder, Topdog/Underdog and Tempest in a Teapot


Marissa McGowan (center) and Cast
Photo by Phillip Hamer Photography
A funny thing happens on the way to today in the musical Ragtime, set in 1906 and inspired by E.L. Doctorow's bestselling novel from 1975. In a charming and ambitious new theatrical revival at Stages St. Louis, everyone speaks of themselves in the third person at the outset, as if they were perfectly content to be frozen in time as a "type" (or possibly a daguerreotype) from the just-ended Victorian era. The wealthy white family we meet at lights-up is very staid, as if we'd discovered them in the pages of an old photo album. And they're quite pleased to stay there, at first, just keeping up appearances in New Rochelle, New York.

But by the end of the lovely two hour and forty-minute play (with intermission), "third person" self-references are out and those people from 1906 have fully emerged from their photo album, bursting with life. In a great invisible evolution, that all-American family will struggle to become dynamic, until they're all speaking in a seemingly new language of "first person direct." Tempered by change and idealism and hard choices, they voyage into a new century to find their own voices, and new ways in Ragtime.

The show began its life as a concept album in early 1996, before opening at Toronto's Ford Centre for the Performing Arts (now the Meridian Arts Centre) that same year. It moved to the now-demised Shubert Theatre in Los Angeles in 1997, before previews on Broadway later that same year. And it had a two-year run there, at the Ford Center for the Performing Arts (now the Lyric), with a star-studded cast. But Ragtime reportedly failed to recoup its initial investment, even though it was nominated for 13 Tony Awards. Its sprawling book won the Tony for Terrence McNally, and its vast unfurling music and lyrics by Stephen Flaherty and Lynn Ahrens earned a Tony for Best Original Score.

In the show, a tsunami of immigrants is fleeing the pogroms of Europe and pouring into New York. A flood of Black Americans has already been coming up from the Jim Crow South for similar reasons. And, in 2024, Ragtime gains a bright new currency with its nostalgic focus on bygone migrant crises.

In his first scene in Harlem, Tamar Greene is stirring and delightful as Coalhouse Walker Jr., a ragtime pianist who makes his own idealistic choice to reunite with his beloved Sarah, played by the splendid Shereen Pimentel. But it may be too late: Sarah is maddened by shame, alone and withdrawn after burying their live newborn child in a stranger's garden. And yet, Sarah and her child do survive under the protection of Mother, part of that wealthy white family we've met in New Rochelle. She makes her first of several hard choices, to take them in.

Mother is played by the excellent Marissa McGowan, with a voice not unlike Kristin Chenoweth's. But Sarah refuses to reunite with Coalhouse, who must first romance her and promises a very modern kind of freedom and self-determination in his shiny new Model T Ford. The twentieth century itself becomes the strange, overwhelming hero, racing around in Ragtime. Stages favorites Steve Isom and John Flack play Henry Ford and J.P. Morgan, respectively, and are unbeatable as always in a long list of quick-change roles. Likewise, the show's multiple groups of choruses dash in and out of scores of first-rate costumes designed by Brad Musgrove.

Favorite numbers include the title song "Ragtime," "Wheels of a Dream," "What a Game" (a funny number about a baseball game as seen from the bleachers), and the act one closer "Till We Reach That Day." Overall, Ragtime (the show) is a sprawling and even magical epic under the direction of Deidre Goodwin. Choreographer Michelle Potterf keeps up with her director every high-stepping kick of the way. And music director E. Reneé Gamez orchestrates a huge stack of lush music and an unusually rich supply of gorgeous singing.

There's very nice onstage work by Kyle Holmes as The Little Boy, and by Dan Fenaughty as his Father. Omega Jones is an imposing presence as Booker T. Washington. Elora Von Rosch is fiery and funny and intellectual as labor organizer Emma Goldman. And Matthew Cox is terrific as Mother's impressionable, progressive Younger Brother.

The night I went, Lindsay Roberts Greene was immaculate stepping into the role of Sarah's Friend, who's also part of an electric Black chorus. Brian Golub and Zoe Klevorn are playful and touching as Latvian immigrants struggling to survive by their wits. And Scott Moreau triggers gasps of shock in the audience as Coalhouse Walker's white tormentor, Willie Conklin.

Patriotism is a nostalgic theme here: Father sells flags and fireworks and bunting, eight years before The Great War ("warn the duke!", The Little Boy chirps presciently, here and there). And twinkling-eyed Sarah Ellis is lovely as a pioneer of American celebrity, the sexy performer Evelyn Nesbit, with a subplot that's one of the most enjoyable in the play. It all fits together because she and nearly all the historical figures on stage seem to paint a circus-like portrait of America, as a spectacular "land of opportunity."

But smirking, imperious Jonathan Cobrda is a counterweight to the irresistible Ms. Ellis, up there on her flying trapeze. He plays the great escape artist Harry Houdini. And contrary to all the other real-life showmen on stage, Houdini seems to promise a much-needed escape for anyone who might still feel trapped in an otherwise bright new age. He holds out hope to anyone who feels they might just as well be wrapped up in chains and sinking under water: that they, too, can find a way out of their troubles, to find a version of the American Dream.

Ragtime runs through October 20, 2024, at Stages St. Louis, Kirkwood Center of Performing Arts, 210 East Monroe Avenue, St. Louis MO. For tickets and information, please visit www.stagesstlouis.org.

Cast (in order of appearance):
The Little Boy: Kyle Holmes
Father: Dan Fenaughty*
Mother: Marissa McGowan*
Mother's Younger Brother: Matthew Cox
Grandfather: Whit Reichert*
Coalhouse Walker Jr.: Tamar Greene*
Sarah: Shereen Pimentel*
Booker T. Washington: Omega Jones*
Tateh: Brian Golub*
The Little Girl: Zoe Klevorn
Harry Houdini: Jonathan Cobrda*
J.P. Morgan: John Flack*
Henry Ford: Steve Isom*
Emma Goldman: Elora Von Rosch
Evelyn Nesbit: Sarah Ellis*
Admiral Perry: John Flack*
Matthew Henson: Joel Oliver*
Judge: Whit Reichert*
Stanford White: Danny McHugh*
Harry K. Thaw: Matthew Marvin*
Kathleen: Caroline Lynch Desmarais
Policeman #1: Danny McHugh*
Child Buyer: Matthew Marvin*
Policeman #2: PJ Palmer
Sarah's Friend: Vera Brown
Trolley Conductor: PJ Palmer
Willie Conklin: Scott Moreau*
Train Conductor: Steve Isom*
Pas de Deux Soloists: Keith Johnson, Jasmine Gobourne
Welfare Official: Caitlin Stebelman*
Baron's Assistant: Elora Von Rosch
Brigit: Elinor Harrison*
Charles S. Whitman: Steve Isom*
Coalhouse Walker III: Amari-Josiah Greene, Kayden Deon Johnson, Laker Taylor

New Rochelle Citizens, Harlem Men and Women, Immigrants, Vaudevillians and Stagehands, Reporters,Ford Workers, Firemen, Millworkers, Strikes, Militia, Bureaucrats and Lawyers, Coalhouse Gang, Spectators, Hotel Staff, Vacationers, Bathing Beauties, and Camera Crew:
Caroline Lynch Desmarais, Sarah Ellis*, John Flack*, Jasmine Gobourne, Skylar Hagerty, Elinor Harrison*, Sophia Hillman, Steve Isom*, Keith Johnson, Omega Jones*, Matthew Marvin*, Danny McHugh*, Scott Moreau*, Joel Oliver*, PJ Palmer, Whit Reichert*, Elora Von Rosch, TJ Staten, Caitlin Stebelman*, Kieran Thompson

Swing:
Brandon Hudson*

Standbys and Understudies:
For Coalhouse Walker Jr.: Joel Oliver*
For Sarah: Lindsay Roberts Greene*
For Mother: Sarah Ellis*
For Tateh: Jonathan Cobrda*
For Father: Danny McHugh*
For Mother's Younger Brother: PJ Palmer*
For Little Boy: Kieran Thompson
For Little Girl: Skylar Hagerty

Dance Captain:
Brandon Hudson*

Fight Captain:
Keith Johnson*

Assistant Dance Captain:
Caroline Lynch Desmarais

Orchestra:
Conductor/Keyboard: E. Reneé Gamez**
Keyboard: Kris Pineda**
Bass/Tuba: Alerica Anderson**
Banjo/Guitar: Travis Mattison
Reeds: Lea Gerdes
Trombone: Evan Palmer
Trumpet: Joe Akers
Violin: Fiona Brickey**
Drums/Percussion: Peter Gunn

Production Staff:
Director: Deidre Goodwin
Choreographer: Michelle Potterf
Music Director/Conductor: E. Reneé Gamez
Scenic Designer: Robert Mark Morgan
Costume Designer: Brad Musgrove
Lighting Designer: Sean M. Savoie
Sound Designer: Julie Ferrin
Wig & Hair Designer: Khadijah Amirah
Additional Orchestrations: Andrew Esquer
Cultural Coordinator: Tavia Rivée Jefferson & Jason Michael Evans
Fight Choreographer: Bart Williams
Production Stage Manager: Monica Dickhens*
Assistant Stage Managers: Britteny Henry*, Gus Kickham
Production Manager: Kimberly Klearman Peterson
Casting: Wojick Casting Team
Artistic General Manager: Alicia Scott-Aune
Marketing Director: Michael Adkins
Company Manager: Elizabeth Dunn
Artistic Director: Gayle Holsman Seay
Executive Director: Andrew Kuhlman

* Denotes Member, Actors' Equity Association

** Denotes Member, American Federation of Musicians of the United States and Canada